There were two minutes and six seconds left in what was arguably the most significant game in the AFC this season. After finishing second to the Patriots so many times, the Pittsburgh Steelers were one defensive stop away from claiming this victory. New England broke the huddle, first down with the ball on their own 23, holding two time outs, but trailing 19-24.
On the first play of the drive, quarterback Tom Brady stepped up into the pocket and tossed the ball toward tight end Rob Gronkowski, running a shallow cross from the offensive right toward the left. But the ball was tipped. Cameron Heyward grazed the ball with his fingertips – enough to throw it off course.
For a small eternity the game – like the football itself – hovered over the turf of Heinz Field. And standing beneath it was Steeler defensive back Sean Davis well positioned to make the game-sealing interception.
But the ball was fluttering unevenly – and it was quite wet from the continuous rain – and it glanced off Sean’s left hand, falling harmlessly to the ground.
And, in that moment, you knew how things would turn out. The exact details of this one couldn’t possibly have been foreseen, but as Davis lay on cold-wet turf mourning the interception that got away, you knew that that was the mistake that would cost Pittsburgh the top seed in the conference.
Consecutive 26-yard passes from Brady to Gronkowski positioned New England at the Steeler 25-yard line. From here, Rob made the play that Davis couldn’t. Brady’s next pass was short and looked like it would land at Gronkowski’s feet. But Rob managed to turn his body back toward the ball and was able to pluck it cleanly before it hit the ground.
New England scored the touchdown on the next play, that – after the two-point conversion (that also went to Gronkowski) – gave New England its 27-24 lead.
At that point, there were 56 seconds left. Just enough time for another fantastic finish.
On the first play of the succeeding Pittsburgh drive, rookie receiver JuJu Smith-Schuster took a short pass over the middle and flanked the New England defense. Sixty-nine yards later he was pulled down on the Patriot ten-yard line. There were 34 seconds left as Pittsburgh called its final time out. Quarterback Ben Roethlisberger then found tight end Jesse James just in front of the end zone. James’ knees touched down short of the goal line, but as no Patriot had touched him he was free to fall the rest of the way into the end zone for the game-winning touchdown.
But not so fast.
As the officials kept reviewing the play and as the announcers in the booth kept cycling through the replay, it began to dawn on everyone that James hadn’t held the ball all the way to the ground. As he was landing in the end zone, he came down ball-first. The impact jarred it enough that it popped loose – just for an instant before Jesse gathered it back in. But that instant was enough. The call on the field was reversed – and Pittsburgh never would score that touchdown.
Even more shocking would be that the Pittsburgh offense wouldn’t even walk off the field with the game-tying field goal. Two plays later – on a play that looked like Ben was going to spike the ball to set up the field goal – Roethlisberger’s end-zone pass was deflected and intercepted. The Patriots had escaped again with a 27-24 victory (game book), and that it came with a twist of controversy made it seem all the more familiar.
Up until those devastating last two minutes, Pittsburgh achieved everything it needed to. Roethlisberger started 15 of 19 with 2 touchdown passes, and the Steelers went 7 for 9 on third downs and held the ball for 19:53 of the first 30 minutes of play. The Patriots went to the locker at the half trailing 17-10 with only 20 yards rushing.
Pittsburgh finished the game out-rushing New England 143-77, with featured back Le’Veon Bell chalking up 117 yards on 24 carries (4.9 yards per). Meanwhile, after superstar wide receiver Antonio Brown left the game with an ankle injury, rookie Smith-Schuster rose to the occasion. His 69-yard catch and run finished his evening with 6 catches (in 6 targets) for 114 yards. Pittsburgh ended the afternoon 10 of 16 on third down while holding New England to just 3 of 9 on that down. The Steelers ended with 35:07 of possession time.
If this were a fantasy league matchup and statistics were the driving force, this would have been a victory for the Pittsburgh Steelers. But this is the lesson that the Patriots repeatedly teach the rest of the NFL. Both Davis and James had the chance to end the game, but neither could finish. When you play New England, you pay dearly for all your mistakes. No matter how well you play through the rest of the game, even slight errors in the fourth quarter will cost you almost every time.
Just ask the Atlanta Falcons and Seattle Seahawks.
Deciding Things in the West
Four weeks into this NFL season, when the Kansas City Chiefs sat at 4-0 and the Los Angeles Chargers had fallen to 0-4, few would have predicted that their December 16 matchup would have been for control of the AFC West. Yet, with LA winning seven of nine after an 0-4 start, and the Chiefs dropping six of eight after winning their first five, both teams brought 7-6 records into last Saturday’s matchup in Arrowhead.
For the Chiefs, the year-long indicator has been the running game. In their 5-0 start, they ran for at least 112 yards in every game, averaging 156.2 yards on the ground. They averaged 33 points a game through the first five. Over the next six games, the running attack slowed to a crawl. They averaged just 76.3 rushing yards in those games. Kansas City lost 5 of the 6, averaging just 18 points a contest.
But the KC tailspin ended just in time – and it was the running game that led out. Even though they lost their Week 13 contest against the Jets, the running attack started to resurface (they finished that game with 112 rushing yards). They ran for 165 in Week 14 while beating Oakland 26-15.
Now hosting LA in Week 15 they carried a tight 10-6 lead into halftime. From there – looking like the early season Chiefs – they rolled to a 30-13 win (game book). While the defense took the ball away four times, the second half belonged to rookie running back Kareem Hunt and his offensive line. Hunt motored for 115 yards on 16 carries, and the team finished with 126 rushing yards on 21 carries.
In the second half alone.
For the game – while quarterback Alex Smith kept the Charger pass defense honest completing 23 of 30 passes (76.7%) – Hunt finished the afternoon with 155 yards rushing, another 51 receiving, and 2 total touchdowns. The Chiefs hung 174 rushing yards onto the Charger defense.
Even with the loss, though, Los Angeles’ playoff chances weren’t damaged all that much. With games remaining in New York against the 5-9 Jets and at home against the 6-8 Oakland Raiders, the Chargers have a legitimate shot at a 9-7 record. They trail three other teams (all currently 8-6) for one of the two wild-card positions. One of those teams (Baltimore) also has a fairly soft closing schedule (they finish at home against 3-11 Indianapolis and at 5-9 Cincinnati). But the other two teams in front of the Chargers face significant challenges.
Buffalo closes its season on the road against the Patriots and Dolphins. Since the Chargers beat Buffalo back in Week 11, if the Bills lose either game they will lose a tie-breaker to Los Angeles based on head-to-head record (assuming LA can win its last two). Meanwhile Tennessee finishes with the 10-4 Rams and the 10-4 Jaguars – a daunting challenge for a team that has lost three of its last five, including back-to-back losses to Arizona (6-8) and San Francisco (4-10).
As expected, New England’s win brings clarity to the top of the AFC playoff picture. The Patriots, the Steelers, the Jaguars and the Chiefs.
At least that’s how it looks now.