Officials – as you may have heard – are human, too. Even the good ones make mistakes. In the replay era, many of those mistakes can be caught, but not all. When an officiating crew has a rough afternoon it’s bad enough. When their bad day seems to tilt in favor of one of the teams, it can lead to significant frustration.
Unfortunately, three of Week Sixteen’s most important games were marred – to a greater or lesser degree – by curious officiating.
Kelvin Benjamin’s Touchdown that Wasn’t
Apparently the weekend’s most controversial call was the replay that overturned a touchdown that Buffalo’s Kelvin Benjamin seemed to score against New England. Buffalo, here, is fighting for its playoff life and the Patriots are trying to tighten their grip on the number one seed in the AFC.
There are 6 seconds left in the first half, and New England is clinging to a 13-10 lead. But the Bills have third-and-goal from the Patriot 4 yard line.
The Bills line up with three receivers bunched to quarterback Tyrod Taylor’s left, and Benjamin split out all by himself to the right, where he would be singled up against Patriot corner Stephon Gilmore. Just before the snap, Gilmore backed up into the end zone in a position to hem Benjamin against the sideline. Taylor lofted the ball to the very back right corner of the end zone, where Benjamin looked for all the world like he caught the pass that would give Buffalo the lead at the half. Field Judge Steven Zimmer – with the play in front of him – was convinced enough to raise his arms for the touchdown.
Moments later – when the touchdown was reversed – there was consternation on the Buffalo sideline. Yet, watching the replay, Kelvin didn’t catch the ball cleanly. He reached with his right hand and batted the ball back toward him. He did drag the left foot along the turf. But only while the ball was fluttering back toward his chest. Once he secured the ball, Benjamin tried again to drag the toe. But it hit against the heel of his right foot instead.
A lot of people in the NFL fandom get quite exercised when calls like this go New England’s way – and I get that. Hating New England is a trendy position to take. And this touchdown certainly could have stood. It was exceedingly close.
But there was sufficient evidence for an overturn – and Buffalo settled for the field goal and the halftime tie.
Patriot quarterback Tom Brady threw only 9 passes in the second half – completing all of them for 105 yards and another touchdown. He finished the game completing 21 of 28 passes (75%). Meanwhile, the Patriot running attack ground away at the Bills. Running back Dion Lewis rolled up 83 yards in the second half on his way to a 129-yard afternoon, and the Patriots finished with 193 rushing yards and 2 touchdowns to finish off Buffalo 37-16 (gamebook). The Bills finished 0-for-4 in the red zone, and scored no offensive touchdowns on the day. Even if the replay had upheld the Benjamin touchdown, it’s exceedingly hard to beat the Patriots scoring just one offensive touchdown.
Merry Christmas to the Los Angeles Rams
In Tennessee the fading Titans spent Christmas Eve struggling for their playoff lives matched against a Rams team that is right in the thick of the NFC playoff picture. In fact, a victory in this contest would punch the Rams’ playoff ticket for the first time since 2004. The officials (it was Walt Anderson’s crew) didn’t do the home team any favors.
At the center of the controversy was a handful of penalties that should have been called, but weren’t. Two of them came on Titan punts. Twice in the second half, Rams special team players pummeled Tennessee punter Brett Kern. Both times Anderson claimed the kicks were partially blocked. It is unlikely the first one was. It is clear the second one was not.
That second missed roughing-the-kicker penalty was probably the more costly of the two. There was 7:31 left in the game and Tennessee trailed by four. They had fourth-and-ten at midfield. The call there gives them a first down on the Ram 35-yard line.
If there was a call more galling to the Titan faithful than either of the missed roughing-the-kicker penalties, it could well have been the missed false start.
There is 7:13 left in the third quarter, with the game tied at 13. The Rams are on the Tennessee 13-yard line, and have decided to go for it on fourth-and-one. As they lined up to run the play, tight-end Tyler Higbee – lined up to the left side – flinched. All of the Titan defenders on that side of the field started pointing and leaping desperately – trying to will the officials to throw a flag.
But they missed it. False starts are almost never missed. I don’t actually remember the last time I saw an offensive lineman get away with a false start. But this one they missed.
Adding injury to insult, instead of being fourth-and-six (forcing a field goal try), the Rams ran the ball right into the area where the Tennessee defenders were flipping somersaults to draw the flag. Ram running back Todd Gurley burst through the distracted defenders for a ten-yard gain. On the next play, Jared Goff tossed the touchdown pass that gave Los Angeles the lead.
Sometimes It’s Best to Just Play
So. Yes, it was an egregious error by the officials. They should have stopped the play and assessed the penalty. But increasingly the players are trying to officiate their games as well as playing them. They spend endless energy reaching for their imaginary flags, as though they had some secret power over the officiating crew. Usually it’s just harmless posing. On this occasion, the Tennessee Titans would have been better served if they had just focused on stopping the play. Had they stopped the Rams there, not only would Los Angeles not have scored the touchdown, but (since it was fourth down) they would not even have had the opportunity to kick the field goal. That one stop – had Tennessee focused on it – may well have won them the game in spite of the officiating.
Sometimes, it’s best to just play.
There is one noteworthy exception to this rule, and that is the case of pass interference. I like to believe this isn’t true, but I swear there are times when the official waits to see if the receiver complains before he throws the flag.
Of course, we can’t let this game pass without mention of the onside kick that wasn’t.
Immediately after Tennessee had tied the score at 20, they ran a hurry-up onside kick. As soon as the official made it to the sideline after marking the ball for play – and while the Rams were still congregating on their sideline – the Titans rushed to the field and bounced an undefended on-side kick that they recovered around the fifty.
Unfortunately, they caught not only the Rams, but the officiating crew off-guard. A flag was thrown. A conference was held, and Walt and his crew decided that the play didn’t count because the Rams had called a time out. Of course, they hadn’t – and after some further discussion the time out was restored to Los Angeles, but the play still never happened. And this is probably just as well for the Titans, as one member of the kickoff team was certainly off-sides, at least half never set, and a couple were running forward with the kicker.
Still in all of this, Anderson and his crew seemed to be several ticks behind. To some degree, they seemed that way the entire game.
Gurley’s Big Day
Of course, Tennessee might have won anyway if they had found an answer for running back Todd Gurley. His 22 rushes for 118 yards added to his 10 catches for 158 yards. He scored two touchdowns, one of them an 80-yard scoring play off of a screen pass. It works out to 276 yards from scrimmage on 32 catches. He was the driving force in Los Angeles’ 27-23 victory (gamebook).
Early Presents for the Saints
But of all the teams saddled with a lump of coal on Christmas Eve, the most frustrated may have been the Atlanta Falcons. They spent the afternoon in New Orleans.
As the game began, Atlanta found itself trailing the Saints for the division lead by one game, and – since they had beaten the Saints two weeks earlier – a win here would give them the tie-breaker. So they were playing Sunday afternoon for no less stakes than the division title.
This game came with an extra-helping of irony. The Falcon win two weeks earlier came with the Saints being flagged 11 times for 87 yards (against only 4 penalties called against Atlanta), and ended with a frustrated coach Sean Payton rushing onto the field to try to get a time out called. The Falcons had been given 9 first downs off Saint penalties that day.
From the very beginning, it was evident that things would be much different in this game. The Falcons drew three penalties in their first two offensive series – including a phantom unnecessary roughness penalty against Devonta Freeman. They were subsequently penalized 3 more times in their next offensive series. Over those first three series, Atlanta pushed for 89 yards of offense, but gave back 59 of them in penalties.
For the game, Atlanta ended up with 10 penalties for 91 yards, while the Saints were only flagged 3 times for 30 yards. But this wasn’t to say that the Saints played a clean game. Notable among the plays the Saints got away with were two fairly obvious pass interferences against Julio Jones. Julio was also involved in the most head-shaking play of the day.
On the very last snap of the third quarter, Atlanta – trailing 20-3 at the time – had third and goal on the New Orleans 6-yard line. Quarterback Matt Ryan tolled to his right and rifled the ball to Jones, standing a yard deep in the end zone. Just behind Jones was Saint cornerback Marshon Lattimore. As the pass arrived in Jones’ hands, Lattimore pushed him out of the end zone. Jones made the catch, but Down Judge Steve Stelljes called him down at the half-yard line.
A myriad of replays from all angles seemed to show that Julio had caught the ball with at least half of the ball over the line. But it wasn’t convincing enough for the replay official to overturn.
As with many other opportunities presented to Atlanta that afternoon, the damage could have been mitigated if they could have pressed their advantage. Facing fourth-and-inches for the touchdown that would put them back in the game, Freeman was buried in the backfield and the ball went over on downs. Devonta Freeman was in the eye of the storm the entire game. He had fumbled away an earlier chance at the one-yard line (in addition to getting called for the phantom penalty).
For the game, Atlanta scored just one red-zone touchdown in four such opportunities. In half of their trips to the red zone – and both of their goal-to-go opportunities – Atlanta came away with no points at all. Additionally, the aroused New Orleans defense sacked Ryan 5 times and held Atlanta to just 2 of 13 on third down. That – in combination with the inconsistent performance of Peter Morelli’s crew – pushed the Saints to a 23-13 victory (gamebook).
My belief going into the weekend was that the teams that ended up winning these games were the teams that I thought were the better teams, so part of me wants to suppose that the Patriots, Rams and Saints would have found ways to win anyway. It’s easy to say that about New England, as they dominated the second half of their game. But the other two contests were quite a bit closer – ten points in the case of the Atlanta game, and Tennessee fell just four points short of their upset. Close enough that a reversal of any of those calls would certainly have profoundly affected the game.
With one game left in the season, Buffalo, Tennessee and Atlanta all still have playoff chances. Tennessee and Atlanta both face significant challenges (Jacksonville and Carolina, respectively). The Bills immediate task (beat Miami) is easier, but they will be playing on the road and will need substantial help (beginning with Cincinnati beating Baltimore).
In all cases, these teams will be hoping for more consistency from the officiating crew.