It’s always difficult to say how things might have turned out.
As Tom Brady and the Patriots broke the huddle with just 10:49 left in the game – and possibly their season – they faced a third-and-18 back on their own 25-yard line. They were trailing by ten points. It’s not fair to say that the entire game rode on this play, but if Jacksonville could stop this one third-and-18 play and run any kind of time off the clock on their next possession, the noose would certainly tighten around the necks of the defending champions.
But, comfortable in the pocket, Brady fired a strike 21-yards down the middle of the field where Danny Amendola gathered it in for the first down. A few moments later, Brady would throw the touchdown pass to Amendola that would set the come-back in motion. To no one’s profound surprise, the Patriots would go on to claim a 24-20 victory (gamebook) and propel themselves into Super Bowl LII.
In one sense, it was classic New England. With them it always seems that when someone needs to make a play, someone does. The grit level on this team is uncommonly high. But there is another aspect of this play (and this game) that will (or at least should) haunt the players, coaches and fans of the Jacksonville Jaguars for the rest of the off-season. On perhaps the game’s pivotal play, Brady looked up to see the Jacksonville defense in cover-4.
The Zone of Woe
In last week’s Divisional Round, Jacksonville had barely survived Pittsburgh. In spite of a seemingly insurmountable early lead, the Steelers kept crawling back into the game, and they did it by the grace of the Jaguar zone defenses (my review of the proceedings is here). Repeatedly, linebackers didn’t drop deep enough or wide enough. Frequently defensive backs abandoned their zone responsibilities to follow a receiver. And time after time they were burned by it.
In the game’s very first series, analyst Tony Romo pointed out that – while the Jaguars had played zone on the first two snaps – the expectation was that they would play the New England receivers almost exclusively with man coverage throughout the game.
There was every reason for him to have this expectation. Tony saw the same thing I did. While they tend to play undisciplined in zone coverage, Jacksonville is among the very best in football at man coverage. In fact, when Brady faced man coverage last Sunday, he was held to just a 45.45% completion percentage, while averaging 5.36 yards per attempted pass. His passer rating against the Jacksonville man-coverage schemes was a pitiable 62.31. When permitted to challenge the Patriots man-on-man, the Jaguar defenders backed up all of their bragging leading up to the game. For all the chatter from and concerning second-year cornerback Jalen Ramsey, the surprising star of the defense was Aaron Colvin who matched the quickness of Amendola almost every chance he had to cover him.
Mystifyingly, he infrequently got that opportunity.
Of his 42 dropbacks, Brady faced man coverage only 12 times – less than 29% of the time. All the rest of the game he saw zone coverages – and relished them. He completed 21 of his 27 passes against the zones he saw (77.78%) for 231 yards – an average of 8.56 yards per attempted pass – with both of his touchdown passes thrown against the Jacksonville zone. His passer rating of 127.01 was more than double his rating against man coverages. And for some un-obvious reason, Brady saw zone coverages over 70% of the time.
I’m not sure if Jacksonville believed that zone coverages could limit New England’s big-play opportunities, but nothing could be farther from the truth. After giving up a bushel-full of big-plays to the Steelers, Jacksonville saw New England complete 5 passes of at least 20 yards, including 2 passes of at least 30 yards against those leaky zones. On the third-and-18 play mentioned above, neither linebacker (Telvin Smith nor Myles Jack) really dropped at all into their zones. They mostly stood still, creating at least a ten-yard gap between them and the secondary – more than enough room for Brady and Amendola to maneuver.
While all of the defensive flaws previously mentioned were in evidence, Jacksonville’s most exploited weak link last Sunday was probably cornerback A.J. Bouye. Excellent in man coverage all year, AJ plays zone as though the concept were to allow the receiver to catch the ball and then make the tackle. Cognizant of not getting beaten deep, Bouye gives ground, and continues to give ground. Of Brady’s 21 completions against zone coverages, no fewer than 5 were passes of at least 10 yards to receivers (mostly Brandon Cooks) who simply ran up the left sideline and turned around to catch the pass. These 5 pass played totaled 69 yards.
Numbers From the Patriot Come Back
Zone or no zone, the game featured the usual Brady heroics. He was 11 for 16 (68.75%) when trailing in the game by at least 10 points – his completions going for 167 yards – an average of 10.44 yards per attempted pass. He also threw the first of his touchdown passes in this circumstance for a passer rating of 123.70. In the fourth quarter alone he was 9 of 14 for 138 yards and both touchdowns. Eight of his 9 fourth-quarter completions achieved first downs. His fourth quarter rating was 136.31. In case you are wondering, that is really good.
Fewer Heroics from Bortles
While Brady’s heroics have come to be expected, the curiosity in this game was the quarterback on the other sideline. The much-maligned Blake Bortles had led his team into the Championship Game with a strong performance against Pittsburgh. His passing line in this game would be good, but deceptively so.
His first appearance in a Championship Game finished with Blake completing 23 of 36 passes for 293 yards and a touchdown – good for a 98.5 rating. But this number comes with a couple of caveats.
First of all, Blake’s great day was pretty much a function of short passes off of play action. Because the Jaguar running game is so proficient, Bortles repeatedly threw off play action. He was 10 of 13 (76.92%) throwing off play action for 158 yards (12.15 per attempted pass) and his only touchdown pass – good for a 142.47 rating. Nine of the ten completions gained first downs.
Additionally, when throwing to receivers who were less than ten yards from the line of scrimmage, Blake completed 18 of 23 (78.26%) for 180 yards and the touchdown – a rating of 113.77%. When throwing to receivers at or beyond ten yards from the line of scrimmage, Blake was only 5 of 13 (38.46%) for 113 yards.
Additionally, Blake faded as the game went along. He began his afternoon hitting 15 of his first 17 passes (88.24%!) for 184 yards and a touchdown. Thereafter, Blake was only 8 for his last 19 (42.11%) for 109 yards. Blake had some late-game opportunities. But he either didn’t notice the receiver, or made a poor pass.
It’s half-way through the third, with the Jags leading 17-10. Bortles is backed up on his own 10-yard line, but rolls to his right and sees Marqise Lee open on a crossing route at the 25 or so, but he heaves the throw into the sideline.
In the waning moments of the third quarter, still 17-10, Jacksonville is first-and-ten on the New England 27. This time it was Allen Hurns wide open up the right sideline, but Blake didn’t see him and dumped the ball off to Ben Koyack in the flat (who dropped the pass).
About half-way through the fourth quarter, still clinging to a 20-17 lead, another pass to Lewis was broken up by Chung. Had he not made up his mind so soon, he would have seen Keelan Cole wide open over the middle for a damaging first down. Instead, Jacksonville punted back to New England.
On their next possession he threw just behind Hurns, losing a first down and bringing up third-and-nine.
On their last desperation drive – trailing now 24-20 with 2:12 left – Bortles miss-connected with Fournette up the left sideline. Even while Lee was uncovering on the right.
Of course, no quarterback – even Brady – hits every pass or notices every open receiver. This is only to point out that while Brady was orchestrating his come-back, Bortles had opportunities as well. There were plays there to be made.
What does all this mean in regards to Bortles? There have been questions surrounding him all season (and I am one the ones who have asked them). How do the Jags evaluate their future at this position? In short, is Blake a quarterback to build around?
I don’t think we can say yet. Certainly this game highlighted the gulf between Bortles and Brady. But, honestly there is a gulf between Brady and everybody. This was also Blake’s first playoff run. I don’t yet know what his ceiling is. But I am left with the distinct impression that the more he played – and especially the more he played in big games – the better and more confident he got. The verdict on Blake is “wait and see.”
Running Against the Patriots
The final great expediency before the Patriots was to stop the Jacksonville running game. In their surprising run that brought them to within about ten minutes of the Super Bowl, the Jaguars unveiled the most prolific running game in the NFL. They averaged 141.4 yards per game on the ground, and scored 18 rushing touchdowns – second most in football. Seven different times during the regular season they rushed for more than 150 yards, including rolling up 231 yards on the Steelers the first time they faced them. In their two playoff victories they stung Buffalo with 155 yards and Pittsburgh with 164. Running the ball was clearly their offensive bedrock and their best chance to upset the invincible Patriots.
But, although they only finished twentieth in the NFL in defending the run, the Patriots run defense – as I have noted – has come together at the season’s most critical juncture. They allowed just 124 rushing yards combined over their last two regular season games and then held Tennessee (coming off a 202-yard rushing performance in their first playoff game) to just 65 yards.
With the early success of the passing attack, Jacksonville opened an early 14-3 lead. That, with an under-rated defensive effort that kept New England in check, allowed the Jaguars to keep attempting to run against New England. Thirty-two times (30 times not counting a couple of kneel-downs by Bortles at the end of the first half) Jacksonville challenged the Patriot run defense. They ran the ball on 19 of their 32 first down plays.
Those 30 legitimate rush attempts netted just 103 yards (3.4 yards per carry). In the second half – when Jacksonville desperately needed to sustain a little offense – it was even worse. Fifteen times they ran in the second half for just 41 yards (2.7 per). After compiling 5 rushing first downs in the first half, they managed just 1 in the second half. Four rushing plays in the fourth quarter – all by Leonard Fournette – totaled just 3 yards. (Note: one of the keys to this success was keeping Bortles in the pocket. After Blake had rushed for 88 yards against Buffalo, he had only the two kneel-downs in this one.)
A significant portion of this success was defensive design. During 18 of those 30 running plays, New England stacked 8 or 9 defenders close to the line of scrimmage. Those running plays earned just 43 yards (2.4 per). The 12 times Jacksonville ran the ball with 7 defenders or less “in the box” they produced 60 yards (5.0 per).
But as in recent weeks, the bulk of this success was the disciplined play of an unheralded collection of defenders who have made a habit of imposing their will on some of the game’s better running games. Again, Malcolm Brown, Trey Flowers and Patrick Chung provided outstanding run defense. Ricky Jean-Francois made more plays than one might suspect.
But standing out to me in this game was a lightly-regarded six-year pro and former seventh-round draft pick playing his first season in New England and his first as a starter. As the game went on, Lawrence Guy began to own it.
Only credited with 3 official tackles against the run, Guy repeatedly held his ground against double-team blocks to stack up the line of scrimmage. Once in the second quarter he pushed the double-team formed against him back into the backfield to disrupt the play. On one third quarter run, he tossed center Brandon Linder aside like so much laundry to make the tackle. As near as I could tell, Lawrence had himself the game of his life in the most important game of his career (so far).
The significance of this development cannot be overstated. With Carson Wentz unavailable for Philadelphia, the Eagles will be faced with the same expediency of running the ball that both the Titans and Jaguars had. Unless they can manage this suddenly elite defensive front any better that Tennessee or Jacksonville, they will almost certainly suffer their same fate.