The field goal attempt was 52 yards – hardly a gimme – but the kick wouldn’t have been good from any distance.
It started wide right, and, as kicker Graham Gano and all of Carolina held their collective breath, it just refused to hook back to the left. At least not enough.
The miss didn’t officially lose the game – the Panthers and the Seattle Seahawks were still tied at 27 – but at that point, everyone pretty much knew what was coming next. Three plays later, Seattle had moved from its own 42 to the Panther 10-yard line. From there, a couple of kneel downs and a spike set up Seahawk kicker Sebastian Janikowski for the game-winning field goal – which he provided as time expired (gamebook) (box score).
In the game’s first half, Panther quarterback Cam Newton had completed all 14 passes thrown. Carolina committed no penalties, allowed no sacks, and outgained Seattle 236 to 154. Seventy-seven of those yards had come on 15 rushing plays (5.1 yards per rush), as Carolina would set the early tone in this contest between two run-first teams.
And yet, the Panthers trotted off to the locker room ahead just 13-10. The culprits were an 0-4 mark on third down, and a 1-4 conversion rate inside the red zone. On their first drive of the game, the Panthers moved to fourth-and-2 at the Seattle 5-yard line. Calling a quarterback draw, Newton waited – perhaps too long – for the blocking to develop and was then pulled down inches short (or so said the official) of the first down.
Two other times, Carolina would have to settle for field goals. It was enough to keep Seattle in the game, and would cost the Panthers in the end.
Carolina would add another 143 rushing yards in the second half – finishing with 220 on the game – but it wouldn’t be enough. Seattle quarterback Russell Wilson would work his own special brand of second half magic. Russell would complete 15 of his last 19 passes (78.9%) for 218 yards and 2 touchdowns to lead the comeback. Much of this came courtesy of two critical deep passes.
Moments after a Bradley McDougald interception in the end zone had denied Carolina yet again in the red zone – and still trailing 13-10 about midway through the third quarter – Wilson found David Moore all alone up the right sideline for 54 yards. Cornerback James Bradberry had slipped in coverage, providing the opportunity. Moments later a touchdown pass to Tyler Lockett gave the Seahawks their first lead of the game.
Now it’s immediately after the Gano miss. Coverage confusion between backup defensive back Corn Elder and Captain Munnerlyn allowed Lockett to uncover deep down the right sideline. That 43-yard completion set up the game-winning field goal.
With the win the Seahawks stay on pace. At 6-5, they now have the tie-breaker over Carolina. If it should come to that. For Carolina, the story is more concerning.
Three weeks ago – after they had pushed around Tampa Bay, 42-28, Carolina held a 6-2 record and looked like a playoff lock. They have now lost three in a row. The streak began with a spanking at the hands of the Steelers (52-21), and proceeded with a loss to an uninspiring Detroit team (20-19). Now, in a kind of must-win game against Seattle at home, the Panthers came up short again.
At 6-5 their playoff position isn’t critical yet. But the trend this team is on is a concern. They still have two games remaining against New Orleans. I have a hard time seeing this team winning either of those – which would bring them to 7 losses. That would mean that they would probably have to win all of their other games. Problem is that two of those other three are on the road – where the Panthers are just 1-4 this season.
The first of those will be this Sunday in Tampa Bay. The Bucs are not in playoff contention this year, but they do play notably better at home, where they are 3-2 this year. Then the Panthers move on to Cleveland. The Browns also are not playoff candidates this year, but they have won two in a row – over Atlanta and Cincinnati – and have played considerably better of late.
An 8-8 record probably won’t get you into the playoffs this year, so Carolina’s path in is to either win both of their next two road games, or win at least one of those two and find a way to win one of the two against New Orleans.
If they should fail – and I think they will have quite a lot of difficulty achieving either of those objectives – then the Minnesota Vikings (6-4-1) are lurking to claim the NFC’s last playoff spot. Minnesota faces a challenging finish as well. They go into New England this week and into Seattle next week. They finish the season at home, but against the rising Chicago Bears. However, they also have a home game against Miami. The game that decides the final NFC playoff berth may well be the road game that the Vikings will play in Detroit in Week 16. The Vikings beat the Lions in Minnesota 24-9 in Week 9.
Denver Halts Pittsburgh’s Win Streak
On the AFC side of the ledger, not much materially changes in the playoff picture. Pittsburgh’s surprising 24-17 loss in Denver (gamebook) (box score) could potentially drop the Steelers to the fourth seed from the third.
In terms of annoying losses, this one might score an eleven on a ten scale. For the afternoon, the Steelers rolled up 527 yards against the Denver defense – ranked twenty-second in the league as the game began. They also committed four turnovers and had a field goal blocked. They also missed three wide open receivers running behind the Denver defense. There are at least a half-dozen scenarios that have Pittsburgh winning this game handily. It was – to say the least – frustrating.
While all of the turnovers hurt, two were particularly damaging.
Trailing 3-0, Pittsburgh took possession on their own 25 with 6:26 left in the first quarter. Eleven plays later, the Steelers had run away all of the remaining time in the quarter, while moving to a third-and-1 at the Denver 24. They began the second quarter with a perfectly executed screen pass to Xavier Grimble, who broke clear up the left sideline. As he approached the goal line with the touchdown that would have given Pittsburgh the lead, Grimble was suddenly met at the one by Will Parks, whose tackle dislodged the ball from Grimble’s grasp. Xavier could only watch as the ball trickled over the goal line and into foul territory – ending the long drive with no points scored, and giving Denver the ball at the 20.
For all of their issues, Pittsburgh nonetheless took possession on their own 44-yard line, trailing by one touchdown, with still 4:26 left in the contest.
Methodically they moved the ball inside the Bronco 5-yard line. With still 1:07 left in the contest, Pittsburgh faced a third-and-goal at the 2-yard line. But the snap to Ben Roethlisberger was wide enough to throw off the timing of the play. Panicked just a bit, Ben heaved the ball into the end zone in the general direction of Antonio Brown. Before it could get there, a defensive lineman named Shelby Harris – who looked for all the world like he was rushing the passer – dropped one step into coverage and found the ball heading right toward him. His goal-line interception provided Pittsburgh with its the final indignity of the night.
Denver has now won consecutive games against teams that have come in riding impressive winning streaks. Their closing schedule is softer than their beginning, encouraging some hope among Bronco fans. I still hesitate to call their playoff chances “good.” In the AFC, both the Chargers and the Colts are likely to win ten games each – meaning the Broncos would have to win out to join that conversation.
On Sunday, they seemed more lucky than good. They will need more than luck to fight their way into the dance.