Joey Votto took Dakota Hudson’s first three pitches of the game. Dak got strikes on the first two before missing with the slider. With the count now 1-2, Hudson came back with a fastball. This pitch would serve him well on this evening, but this particular fastball was up and out over the plate. Joey chopped it over the mound and over the second base bag. Shortstop Paul DeJong got to it, but had no play – infield hit for Votto.
By game’s end, this would be a mere footnote in the Cards 7-5 victory (boxscore), but in a sense, they almost should have stopped the game and given Joey the ball. That hit snapped an 0-for-27 streak that batters had against Hudson when in two-strike counts. The streak stretched back to the first inning of the August 16 game against the White Sox when Tim Anderson bounced a 3-2 pitch through into right for a single.
Votto’s single would also be the last two-strike hit the Reds would get last night. Thirteen more would go down against Hudson, and six more against the bullpen.
During his two-strike no-hitter (of sorts), Dak struck out 12 of the 27. Ten others grounded out. Of the five that managed to get the ball in the air against Dakota, two were infield pop-outs. The last 13 Cincy batters to face Hudson with two strikes on them either struck out (7) or grounded out (6).
Clearly two-strikes is a bad place to be with Hudson on the mound. Especially since the season re-started for the Cardinals, Dakota has employed that slider/heavy sinker combination to deadly effect. Over his last 4 starts, batters are 2 for 42 (.048) against him in two-strike counts.
The Cardinal pitchers, who (at .133) have baseball’s third lowest batting average once they get to two strikes (according to baseball reference), have four other prominent pitchers holding batters under .100 in these counts. Hudson’s is the lowest – the others being Alex Reyes (.063), Giovanny Gallegos (.067), Kwang Hyun Kim (.080), and Jack Flaherty (.091).
For their part, the offense was only 3 for 19 (.158) with two strikes on them. Yet two of those were two of the most important hits of the game – both coming with two outs as well.
With the game tied at one in the second inning, Kolten Wong fell behind Cincinnati starter Anthony DeSclafani 0-2 with runners on first and third (and two outs). Kolten poked a fastball the other way through the left side for the single that gave the team the lead it never relinquished.
Two innings later, St. Louis loaded the bases (with two outs) for DeJong. Paul capped a six-pitch at bat by jumping on a 3-2 slider that hung down the middle of the plate, launching it over the centerfield wall for his first career grand slam.
Few things in baseball are more deflating than surrendering important hits with two strikes and two outs.
Starters Still Flexing
For the evening, Hudson finished 7 innings allowing just 1 earned run on only 4 hits. Hudson has tossed consecutive quality starts, and over his last 4 starts, Dak holds a 1.66 ERA. He has surrendered just 10 hits over those innings, only 2 for extra-bases. Opposing batters are hitting just .137 against Hudson with a .192 slugging percentage since the re-start.
Over their last 21 games, Cardinal starters hold a 2.62 ERA with a .166 batting average against.
Picking up where he left off last year, Giovanny Gallegos picked up last night’s save. He has allowed no runs so far through 8 innings, and barely any hits. Both batters Giovanny faced last night were quickly forced into two-strike counts and both struck out. So far Gallegos has faced 24 batters this season – with 16 facing a two-strike count. His ratio of 66.7% is the highest of any Cardinal pitcher who has faced at least 20 batters. Of those, nearly two-third (10) strike out. That percentage (62.5) is the highest on the staff of any pitcher who has faced at least 10 batters.
He may prove difficult to remove from the closer’s role – even after Jordan Hicks comes back next year.
While the big hit and the due accolades will go to the other Paul in the lineup, Paul Goldschmidt was 3-3 with a walk and a hit-by-pitch last night, picking up where he left off at the end of the homestand. Goldy is now 6 for his last 12, and is hitting .359 (23 for 64) since the team came out of quarantine.
Goldy drove in a first inning run with a double on an 0-1 pitch. The count on him was 2-1 leading off the third when he was hit by a pitch. He walked on a 3-1 pitch ahead of DeJong’s grand-slam in the fourth. The count was 2-1 in the sixth when he singled. He finished in the eighth with an infield hit on a 1-1 pitch.
This seems to have become Goldschmidt’s comfort zone during a plate appearance. He rarely offers at the first strike, but doesn’t want the pitcher to get the advantage that comes with that second strike. So he is – especially after the re-start – sitting on that second strike. He is 13 for his last 25 (.520) with a .760 slugging percentage in one-strike counts over the last 21 games.
Kolten’s RBI single snapped an 0-for-15 skid. His average had dwindled to .202 before he finished with 2 hits in his last 4 at bats.
Tommy Edman continued his resurgence from a sluggish start to the season. Edman had his second consecutive two-hit game last night, and has now hit safely in 7 of his last 8. He is hitting .344 (11 for 32) in those games.
Much like Goldschmidt, Edman has been thriving on that one-strike pitch since the end of the quarantine. Both of last night’s hit came on one-strike pitches, and Edman is 9-for-20 (.450) over the last 21 games on those pitches.
About the same time that Edman started to figure things out, Paul DeJong, playing in his second game since the quarantine, also started to click in. One game after he contributed three hits in the finale against the Indians, Paul slapped out two more hits (including the big home run) against the Reds. DeJong has hits in 6 of his last 8 games – with four of those being multi-hit games. He was 0-for-4 in his first game back on the field. Since then, he is a .406 hitter (13-for-32).
After settling into the everyday designated hitter role, Brad Miller has hit his first little dry spell of the season. Hitless in 4 at bats last night (with 3 strikeouts), Brad is now 0 for his last 10.
Carpenter Draws a Walk
Matt Carpenter did, indeed, draw a walk (two, actually) and came around to score a run after one of them. Matt has drawn at least one in 9 of his last 11 games, for a total of 11. And while that certainly has value, actual hits off of Carpenter’s bat have been notably rare. Over his last 7 games he is 1 for 18 (.056) and over the last 11, Carp is a .100 hitter (3 for 30) with only one extra-base hit. Carpenter is down to .181 for the season.
But he is walking a lot.
After a brief surge, Dylan Carlson’s average has plunged back below the .180 mark (he’s at .176). Hitless in 4 at bats last night, Carlson is now 1 for his last 12 (.083).
Paul Goldschmidt’s first-inning RBI double drove in the first run of the game. The Cards had gone eight games (since their August 24 game against Kansas City) without scoring the first run of a game.
My Designated Hitter Rant
As the DH seems to be a real threat in the near future – and many expect it to be universal and permanent by 2022 if not sooner – I am going to include the link to my DH rant at the bottom of all my baseball posts this year (and next, probably). If you have already read it, you should know that I added a section on July 30 after the Cards first five games with the DH. Here is the link. If this idiocy is to become law, I want to do everything I can to make sure as many people as possible understand why this is wrong.