According to the various game reports, the Green Bay Packers were cruising early last Sunday, as they pulled out to a 10-0 lead over the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. This lasted right up to the 12:50 mark of the second quarter, when a Tampa Bay cornerback named Jamel Dean stepped in front of Packer receiver Davante Adams and intercepted Aaron Rodgers’ pass – returning it 32 yards for the touchdown. With that play flipping the momentum, the Bucs came roaring back for the victory.
There is, of course, a strong element of truth there. Tampa Bay did go on to score the final 38 points on the evening in a convincing 38-10 victory (gamebook) (summary). The truth, as usual, is more nuanced than that. Even before this particular tipping point, there were signs that all was not right with the Packers. Rodgers – beyond the interception – endured what must surely be one of the worst games of his storied career, but the fault extends well beyond Aaron’s struggles as he was widely let down by his teammates – and, for that matter, even the design of the offense contributed to the lopsided loss.
If that wasn’t bad enough, the Packers ran into a Tampa Bay team playing its most complete game of the season. The offense was near flawless as they committed no turnovers, committed no penalties, suffered no sacks, and went 4-for-4 in the red zone. Defensively, they played much tighter in their zone coverages than they have previously, and, from about the mid-point of the third quarter on, they switched to stifling man coverages that I didn’t know they had in them.
For Green Bay, it all amounted to an imperfect storm.
Starting With Aaron
From the very beginning of the game, Rodgers was playing fast and a little on the frenetic side. With 11:27 left in a still scoreless first quarter, the Packers dialed up a quick wide receiver screen to Equanimeous St. Brown along the left sideline. But the moment the ball reached Rodgers hands, he spun and immediately fired the ball, well before St. Brown could possibly turn around and catch it.
Arguably, his most frazzled moment came with 5:24 left in the first – with the Packers up 3-0, facing a first-and-10 on the Buccaneer 41. His first target on the play was Adams on a quick out. The window would have been a little tight, but Rodgers has made tighter throws than that. For whatever reason, though, he decided against it and pulled the ball down. Just in front of him, he had Aaron Jones wide open underneath the zone. But Aaron couldn’t pull the trigger.
At this point, although the pocket was still fairly secure, Rodgers bolted, spinning out to his left. He pumped to throw, but pulled the ball down, and spun again back to his right – all but running right into William Gholston – a Tampa Bay defensive lineman. Escaping his grasp, Aaron scrambled back to his right where he fired the ball out of bounds in the general direction of Adams.
In spite of this shakiness, Aron recovered enough to finish off the touchdown drive, and finished the first quarter 8 for 12.
His first play of the second quarter found Aaron escaping the pocket again at the first hint of pressure. After more scrambling, he threw high to Jones in the flat. On second down, Rodgers rolled right on a naked boot. No one had blocked Jason Pierre-Paul, who seemed more interested in containing Rodgers than forcing the issue. As Aaron meandered toward the right sideline, with JPP keeping a watchful eye on him, he had some opportunities. He had TE Robert Tonyan underneath and he had Malik Taylor at the sticks. But Rodgers didn’t throw the ball until he threw it away the moment before he went out of bounds.
On the next play, he threw the first of his two game-changing interceptions.
Unsettled by the Blitz
It wouldn’t be accurate to say that Rodgers was relentlessly blitzed, but DC Todd Bowles did make that extra rusher a substantial part of his game plan. Of the 41 times that Aaron dropped back, he saw an extra rusher 18 times (43.9%). In spite of the fact that 3 of the 4 sacks that Tampa Bay recorded against Aaron came on the blitz, they weren’t generally effective in getting pressure on the Green Bay quarterback. What it did do, though, was to speed up his clock. Almost always, as soon as he saw the blitz coming, Rodgers would immediately unload the ball.
This is what happened on both of his interceptions. On the first one, Sean Murphy-Bunting was coming unblocked from the secondary. But he was still more than five yards away from Rodgers when Aaron quickly snapped the ball to a covered Adams. On third down of the subsequent possession, Tampa Bay sent 6 rushers. In spite of the fact that the blitz was pretty much completely picked up, Aaron rushed the throw to Adams, who hadn’t achieved any kind of separation from CB Carlton Davis. The ball was batted by Davis (or Adams) and may have been tipped at the line by JPP. It eventually ended up in the arms of safety Mike Edwards, who returned the pick to the two-yard line. One play after that, Tampa Bay had a 14-10 lead.
The day didn’t get any worse than that for Rodgers, but it never got much better. He made other rushed decisions and passes. Other times, he had open receivers that he just threw poorly to. It was a day that Aaron could certainly have used some help from his teammates. He wouldn’t get it.
Little Help from His Friends
For their part, the rest of the offense had a correspondingly bad day. The offensive line was spotty in protection – especially against the blitz – and running back Jamaal Williams (one of the Packers’ most improved players) was repeatedly unable to pick up blitzing linebackers and defensive backs.
As for the receivers, they were officially charged with 6 dropped passes – although a few of those were a little unfair. Marcedes Lewis was charged with a drop on a throw that was well beyond him. His dive for it brought him close enough to have the ball brush off his fingertip. Nonetheless, there were enough legitimate drops to add to Aaron’s frustrations.
Even the usually reliable Davante Adams contributed to the offensive malaise. He was charged with two drops of his own, and, with Green Bay facing a third-and-8 with 5:40 left in the third, he uncovered on a deep throw up the right sideline and hauled in one of Aaron’s best and most confident throws of the game. But the pass was ruled incomplete, as Adams – who caught the ball with his back to the sideline – failed to negotiate the sideline and stepped out of bounds.
At least a half-dozen other times, Rodgers stared into the teeth of Tampa Bay’s zone defenses only to find he had no outlet or underneath route to dump the ball off to. I’m not sure I’ve ever seen a game plan that routinely didn’t provide for check-down routes against the zone defenses they knew they would see.
The futility was general – and seemed to effect the entire team.
If I were to speculate on a reason – other than it was just one of those days – I might point to the lack of the running game.
Running the ball against the Bucs has become almost legendarily difficult. Last year, they allowed an average of just 73.8 rushing yards per game, and only 3.3 yards per carry – both figures were the best in the NFL. This year so far they have been even better. They came into the Packer game surrendering just 58.4 rushing yards per game, and only 2.7 yards per carry – again, both numbers were the NFL’s best.
In spite of the fact that the Packers were among football’s best running teams (averaging 150.8 yards per game and 5.1 yards per attempt), Green Bay’s response was to give up on the run before they even took the field. They ran the ball just 10 times in the first half, and only 21 times on the day – many of those late in the fourth after the contest was decided.
Over the last few seasons, the Packers have become more reliant on the balance their running game provides than, perhaps, even they are aware. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the abandonment of this foundation of their offense wasn’t a contributing factor in the general disorientation that the offense experienced. I wrote a couple days ago about identity. Green Bay surrendered an important chunk of its identity before the game even kicked off.
Recognizing the Defense
In caviling the various elements of the Packer offense, I’m afraid some readers might understand this as minimizing the contributions of the Buccaneer defense. That couldn’t be farther from my intentions.
If anything, last Sunday’s game served as a coming out party for one of the NFL’s most compelling defensive units. Through their first 5 games, their patented zone defenses were distressingly squishy. Only four teams in football started Week Six allowing a higher completion percentage than the Bucs –a problematic 70.9%.
There was none of that on Sunday (helped, of course, by the fact that Green Bay frequently didn’t provide for a check down). Rodgers came in completing 70.5% on the season. He left town having completed just 16 of 35 – 45.7%.
But as tight as the zone coverages were, the revelation to me from the game was the Tamp Bay Buccaneers in man coverage – especially Carlton Davis, who was generally Adams’ escort for the evening.
Davis didn’t shut out Green Bay’s most dangerous receiver, but he pretty much played him to a draw. Adams finished with 6 catches, but for just 61 yards, no touchdowns and no plays longer than 18 yards. And without explosive plays from Davante, the rest of the receiving corps was fairly easily silenced. Number two receiver – Marquez Valdes-Scantling covered mostly by Murphy-Bunting – found precious little space. He finished with 3 catches for 32 yards. Taylor has become Green Bay’s the third receiver – he had no receptions and only one target.
Green Bay’s Persistent Concern
Once again, the question comes down to receiving depth in Green Bay. It was a worry last year. It was part of the angst of the recent draft. And on Sunday, it came back to bite them again. One of the reasons – I believe – that Tampa Bay was so comfortable in calling man coverages was because after Adams, the Packers didn’t have anyone that would strike fear into them.
In a Week Three win over New Orleans, Allen Lazard erupted with a 146-yard receiving game – and immediately went on IR. His return might have a sizeable impact on this offense.
But for right now, no one knows when that return will be. And no one seems to have any other immediate answers.