The way that the Cardinal’s hot streak came to a thudding halt against Houston at home this weekend should serve as a reminder of some fundamental principles. The first of these principles affirms that it is the depth of the lineup – not necessarily whatever impact bats might be in the middle of it – that determines your offensive performance.
Toward the end of the Cardinal hot streak (and most recently here), the mlb.com game accounts have connected the St Louis surge to Paul Goldschmidt’s recent heroics.
It is no surprise that sports’ journalists should – like the fans – gravitate towards the achievements of the game’s superstars. Sunday’s loss brought to an end a six-game home run streak from Goldschmidt (although not his hitting streak – more on that below). This is a significant achievement. There are precious few mortals anywhere on this planet who are capable of doing things like this.
But the structure of baseball minimizes the impact of any one player – even the superstars. Unlike football (where you can give the ball to your star running back as often as you like) or basketball (where you can funnel the ball to your top scorer every time down the court), in baseball, Goldschmidt has to wait until everyone else has had their at bat before he can hit again. Thus, the more production you get from the rest of the lineup, the more runs you will score over the course of the game (or season).
This was somewhat dramatically born out in the Cardinal losses in this last series. Paul homered in the Saturday game, and added a single on Sunday, but St Louis scored just two runs in each game because too few of the rest of the Cardinal hitters were able to contribute.
It feels a little obvious pointing this out, but there are times that I’m not sure that management understands that this is how offense works in baseball.
The other fundamental principle is that everything begins with pitching. Paul may well have hit two home runs in each of the last two games, and the birds would probably have lost them both anyway as the starting pitchers in those two contests never really gave the team a chance.
In the Friday game (a 5-3 win), starter Jack Flaherty crafted a quality start against this very accomplished Houston lineup – he allowed just 2 runs on 3 hits over 6 innings (he struck out 9).
In the other two games – Saturday’s 8-2 loss and Sunday’s 6-2 defeat – the two starters (Daniel Ponce de Leon and Dakota Hudson) made early exits, leaving with significant deficits.
Combined, Ponce de Leon and Hudson totaled 6.1 innings at the cost of 10 runs on 11 hits (that included a double and 3 home runs), 6 walks and 1 hit batter. They combined for a 14.21 ERA and a .407/.529/.778 batting line.
Most of the time, this kind of damage will get you into trouble. On Saturday and Sunday, it was more trouble than the offense could overcome.
While the Astro series represented a step backward for the rotation overall, Flaherty’s performance continued his strong rebound. After enduring some notable growing pains through much of the first half, Jack began turning things around with his last start before the All-Star break (a 1-0 loss).
Over his last four starts, now, Jack has 3 quality starts. In his 24.1 innings, he has given just 4 runs on 14 hits while striking out 30. He has a 1.48 ERA and a .165 batting average against, but still no wins as his offense has supported him with just 4 total runs over that span.
His ERA for the month of July is now down to 2.48 with a .198 batting average against.
The only runs off Jack came on a two-run home run off the bat of Michael Brantley. The runner (Alex Bregman) was on first with one out – a potential double play opportunity. This now makes 35 straight double play opportunities that Jack hasn’t gotten the double play on a ground ball. A fly ball pitcher, Jack has actually gotten 5 ground balls in those situations, but 3 of those grounders found their way through the infield for singles, and the other two resulted in force-outs only.
Flaherty did actually get one double play in all of those opportunities. Against the Pirates on July 16, Jack struck out Elias Diaz while Kevin Newman was running. Matt Wieters gunned Newman down to complete the DP.
With their 50 swings at Jack’s offerings, Houston was only able to put the ball in play with 12 of them (24%). Flaherty has been the most difficult of all Cardinal starters to put the ball in play against. For the season, only 32.5% of the swings against him end up in play.
Flaherty had – overall – great success against Houston. That success came at a price, though, as it took him 108 pitches to fight through his six innings (the ‘Stros fouled off 28 pitches against him). He averaged 4.91 pitches per batter faced.
As is common for strikeout pitchers, Jack throws a lot of pitches per batter. For the season, his 4.19 pitches per batter faced is the highest among all starters who have been in the rotation all year.
Ponce de Leon
Daniel pitched his way into the rotation with four very impressive spot starts. He has now relinquished that spot as he hasn’t pitched well since being named the fifth starter. In his last three starts he has totaled 9 innings pitched, giving 10 runs on 14 hits and 10 walks. Opponents have a .368 batting average and a .500 on base percentage against him in those outings.
After a strong start, Daniel now has a 4.87 ERA for the month with 11 walks in 20.1 innings.
At one point earlier this season, Dakota Hudson had thrown 8 consecutive quality starts – a feat unapproached by anyone in the rotation this year.
But Dakota has been undergoing some growing pains of his own lately. His last 6 times out, Hudson has been saddled with a 5.46 ERA, a .301 batting average against, and a .593 slugging percentage against. He has been touched for 9 home runs in his last 28 innings.
Normally an extreme groundball pitcher, only 43 of the last 89 batters to put the ball in play against him have hit the ball on the ground (48%).
John Brebbia tossed a scoreless inning on Friday and then threw two more on Sunday. While he has had some ups and downs this season, overall there have been a lot more ups.
In 10 games (14 innings) since his paternity leave, Brebbia has allowed 4 runs on 9 hits, walking 2 while striking out 19. His July ERA sits at 2.57, with a .180/.226/.240 batting line against.
Of the two hits John allowed, one was an infield hit. Through the end of June, John had allowed just one infield hit. He has been scratched for 4 this month.
Over the two games, John faced 3 double play opportunities, and didn’t get the ground ball for any of them. For the season, Brebbia has been in that double play situation 32 times and has gotten just 1 double play. He only got ground balls on two other occasions – one resulting in an infield hit, and the other a dribbler back to the mound that advanced the baserunners.
Of the two batters that John struck out on Sunday, one (Carlos Correa) was caught looking at strike three. Brebbia is getting more called third strikes than usual lately. Of his first 48 strikeouts this season, only five looked at strike three. Seven of his last 17 strikeouts have gone down looking.
No Cardinal pitcher who has faced more than 50 batters has had a higher percentage of his pitches swung at than John. Over the weekend, Houston offered at 21 of his 39 deliveries (53.8%). For the season, batters swing at his offerings 51.1% of the time.
After a brilliant start to his season, John Gant has been regressing rapidly. He pitched in 2 of the Houston games, and allowed a run in both. He has been scored on in 5 of his last 12 games. In a total of 10 innings, the previously almost untouchable Mr Gant has given 9 runs on 16 hits a 9 walks – his 8.10 ERA in those outings accompanied by a .381 batting average and a .490 on base percentage.
Sunday was one of the few times recently that John was brought into a game the Cards were losing, and the four-run deficit they faced was the farthest behind the Cards have been when John has entered a game this season.
In the eighth inning Sunday, Brantley came to the plate with George Springer at third, Jose Altuve at first and no one out. The score was 5-1 Houston. Brantley drilled a double off the base of the wall in right-center driving in the runner from third. This was the eleventh time this season that Gant had that runner at third and less than two out. That runner has now scored 8 times.
With his pinch home run in Sunday’s ninth inning, Dexter Fowler extended his recent hitting streak to six straight games. Dex is hitting .304 (7 for 23) during the streak, with 4 of the hits going for extra bases (2 doubles and 2 home runs) – a .652 slugging percentage.
Tyler O’Neill was also one of the bright spots of the Houston series. Extracting himself from a small slump, O’Neill was 4 for 10 in the 3 games, with 3 walks. Tyler is still having a very strong July, hitting .312 this month (24 for 77).
As mentioned above, Paul’s home run streak ended at six games. Goldschmidt did, though, get a single on Sunday to push his hitting streak to seven games. He is 10 for 29 during the streak (.345) with 4 singles to go with the 6 home runs – a .966 slugging percentage.
Kolten Wong had gotten a hit in 8 consecutive games in which he had had a plate appearance until he went 0 for 3 on Saturday. He started his next streak with a single and a run scored on Sunday.
In the last 10 games in which he has had a plate appearance, Kolten is hitting .371 (13 for 35). He is up to .344 (22 for 64) for the month.
After his big series against Pittsburgh, Paul DeJong finished the Houston series just 1 for 9. He is still hitting just .225 (18 for 80) in July.
Nothing will drop in for Harrison Bader. Hitless in 5 at bats during the Houston series, Harrison is now 0 for his last 14 at bats. He is hitting .146 for the month (6 for 41), and is down , now, to .195 on the year.
Not much went Yairo Munoz’ way against Houston, either. Hitless in 8 at bats in the series, Yairo is now working on an 0-for-10.
Over his last 6 games, Yairo is 4 for 24 (.167), and is now hitting just .233 (14 for 60) for the month.
Final Notes from the Pirate Series
Yairo Munoz got the start in left field on Wednesday, breaking Tyler O’Neill’s streak of 11 consecutive starts in left. That had been the longest active streak by any Cardinal at a single position. That mantle now reverts back to Paul DeJong, who – after the conclusion of the Houston series – has made 14 consecutive starts at shortstop.
While Miles Mikolas – the Thursday starter – has pitched notably better since the All-Star break, he is still well on pace to set new career highs (all set last year) in runs, earned runs, hits allowed and walks. He gave 3 more runs (all earned) on 5 more hits and a walk in his six innings, and has now served up 58 runs (56 earned) on 127 hits and 20 walks for the season. His career highs were the 70 runs (63 earned), 186 hits and 29 walks he gave last year. At his current pace, Miles will give up 92 runs (89 earned), 202 hits and 32 walks this season.
With their 6 runs on Thursday, St Louis finished the series with 30 runs scored – the most runs they have scored in any series this year (of course, this was a four-game series). The previous high was the 26 runs they scored against the Dodgers from April 8-11 (also a four-game series).
NoteBook – Houston Series
Paul Goldschmidt picked up his seventh GWRBI with his Friday home run. He is 2 behind Marcell Ozuna for the team lead.
When St Louis out-homered Houston 2-1 on Friday, they brought themselves into home run parity for the season for the first time since the twelfth game of the season (they were actually ahead of the opposition at that point, 19-18). The Cards ended Friday with 134 home runs hit and 134 home runs allowed. As recently as game number 90 (on July 13), they were 16 home runs shy of the opposition (109 hit and 125 allowed).
With his 3 at bats on Thursday, Dexter Fowler surpassed the 289 at bats he totaled in his slump-and-injury plagued 2018 season. Dexter now has 292 at bats for the 2019 season.
Carlos Martinez has started at least 1 game every year of his seven-year career. On Friday he pitched in his twenty-fifth game of the year – all out of the pen. He is 8 games pitched away from the 33 he pitched last year, when he was mostly a starter. Even after missing the first part of the season with injuries, Carlos is still on pace to pitch in 39 games, which would be his most since he pitched in 57 games when he was mostly a reliever in 2014.
But no starts, yet.
Carlos has already set career highs in games finished (17, after finishing 13 in 2014) and saves (he has 10 this season after recording just 7 previously in his entire career).
One thing about Kolten Wong’s season. He won’t be able to complain that he did have ample opportunity. Kolten, who has had annual issues staying healthy (and producing enough to stay in the big leagues) played his 103rd game of the season on Sunday. He played only 127 all last year. His 10 at bats in the series brought him to 328 for the season. He totaled 353 all last year.
The consistent playing time has seemed to pay off some. Wong already has 85 hits (with his 3 against Houston) and 128 total bases this year, after finishing last year with 88 hits and 137 total bases.
He already has more runs batted in this year (40 after his Friday RBI) than he had all of 2018 (38).
When the Friday game started, St Louis had gone 8 games being at least tied in the game after 6 innings, but they trailed in this one by a 2-1 score at that point of the game.
In Saturday’s loss they broke a streak of ten straight games where they held the lead at some point of the game.
George Springer’s home run in the first inning on Sunday meant that Houston scored first in all three games of the weekend set. The Cardinals have now surrendered the first run in five of the last six games.
St Louis is now 11-5-1 in series after winning the first game.